As we progressed, the trail diminished, and the class slowly increased from II to low-level III, or maybe II+. It became evident that this probably wasn't the correct route to the saddle area. However, for most of the time, we were too close the slopes to see any peaks and get a good feel for location. But when you're on a trail, or at least think you're on one, it seems to motivate you to continue. Ultimately, we were on or near a real trail, just the wrong one. The ridge, we were skirting was the base of Donner Ridge (I believe it's called), which separates Spectacle Lakes from the basin between Chiquita and Ypsilon. So we got an unexpected chance to see Spectacle Lakes.
From here, my nephew and brother-in-law split from the group, ascended a class II section of the ridge. Sandy, Ali, and I descended the slabs, and worked our way around the base of the ridge to the correct side. We didn't like the idea of not knowing what was on the other side of the ridge (although it turned out to be doable class II-III grassy ledges and slabs). I'd have taken more pictures, but I already lost my lens cap during prior scrambling, and just got it out to snap a shot of the lakes. That's 2 of my lens caps out there in RMNP!
There were a couple of exposed points on our route up. The kind that are ok in one direction, but not the other. While backtracking, I kept skirting around the base of the ridge, maintaining elevation as long as possible. This is the sort of stuff we were descending.
I found a good route that avoided all areas of concern.
3 of 7