Posted 06 June 2008 - 08:41 AM
Welcome, Tigerv1. It's just a matter of taste and personal decision.
For me, I think the fall colors are well worth putting up with the crowds, because I can ALWAYS outwit the crowds and find solitude no matter how many people are there. The worst crowds, traffic and weather conditions I've ever endured were in mid-July, and like Sandy, I said never again.
I was there the same week Sandy and Bill were in Sep 2006 and that was an unusually weird weak weather-wise with early snow and road closings. It so happened, the week after we came home was perfect! If only we'd gone the 4th week instead of the third! Weather is an iffy thing at RMNP, no matter what season.
I have been several times in very late Sep, the last week, and OFRR was still open, TRR too, the weather was perfect, the fall colors were at their best, I couldn't have asked for anything more perfect. My son climbed to the top of Ypsilon the last week of Sep. So the week that Sandy and Bill were there in 2006 was just a flukey year and shouldn't be considered the norm. I sure won't let that one bad weather week deter me from late Sep trips.
The thing I don't like about late August is that the snowy peaks are gone, (you might see an early dusting of snow, I know I did last year in late Aug) and the aspen haven't yet begun to turn, and to me, that is just the ultimate sight, to see those golden aspen.
But everybody has their own opinion, that's just mine. I love fall and the golden aspen. The rut is neat too, but for me that is secondary to the color.